| | AFC |
| | QB - Tom Brady(NE) - Peyton Manning (IND), Ben Roethlisberger (PIT) |
| | RB - LaDainian Tomlinson (SD) - Joseph Addai (IND), Willie Parker (PIT) |
| | FB - Lorenzo Neal (SD) |
| | WR - Randy Moss (NE), Reggie Wayne (IND) - Braylon Edwards (CLE), T.J. Houshmandzadeh (CIN) |
| | TE - Antonio Gates (SD) - Tony Gonzalez (KC) |
| | T - Matt Light (NE), Jason Peters (BUF) - Jonathan Ogden (BAL) |
| | G - Alan Faneca (PIT), Logan Mankins (NE) - Kris Dielman (SD) |
| | C - Jeff Saturday (IND) - Dan Koppen (NE) |
| | DE - Jared Allen (KC), Kyle Vanden Bosch (TEN) - Jason Taylor (MIA) |
| | DT - Albert Haynesworth (TEN), Vince Wilfork (NE) - Jamal Williams (SD) |
| | OLB - James Harrison (PIT), Mike Vrabel (NE) - Shawne Merriman (SD) |
| | ILB - DeMeco Ryans (HOU) - Ray Lewis (BAL) |
| | CB - Champ Bailey (DEN), Asante Samuel (NE) - Antonio Cromartie (SD) |
| | FS - Ed Reed (BAL) |
| | SS - Bob Sanders (IND) - Troy Polamalu (PIT) |
| | K - Rob Bironas (TEN) |
| | P - Shane Lechler (OAK) |
| | KR/PR - Josh Cribbs (CLE) |
| | Special Teams - Kassim Osgood (SD)
|
| | NFC |
| | QB - Brett Favre (GB) - Matt Hasselbeck (SEA), Tony Romo (DAL) |
| | RB - Adrian Peterson (MIN) - Marion Barber (DAL), Brian Westbrook |
| | FB - Tony Richardson (MIN) |
| | WR - Larry Fitzgerald (ARI), Terrell Owens (DAL) - Donald Driver (GB), Torry Holt (STL) |
| | TE - Jason Witten (DAL) Chris Cooley (WAS) |
| | T - Flozell Adams (DAL), Walter Jones (SEA) - Chris Samuels (WAS) |
| | G - Leonard Davis (DAL), Steve Hutchinson (MIN) - Shawn Andrews |
| | C - Andre Gurode (DAL) - Matt Birk (MIN) |
| | DE - Aaron Kampman (GB), Patrick Kerney (SEA) - Osi Umenyiora (NYG) |
| | DT - Kevin Williams (MIN), Pat Williams (MIN) - Tommie Harris (CHI) |
| | OLB - Julian Peterson (SEA), DeMarcus Ware (DAL) - Lance Briggs (CHI) |
| | ILB - Lofa Tatupu (SEA) - Patrick Willis (SF) |
| | CB - Al Harris (GB), Marcus Trufant (SEA) - Terence Newman (DAL) |
| | FS - Sean Taylor (WAS) - Ken Hamlin (DAL) |
| | SS - Darren Sharper (MIN) |
| | K - Nick Folk (DAL) |
| | P - Andy Lee (SF) |
| | KR/PR - Devin Hester (CHI) |
| | Special Teams - Brendon Ayanbadejo (CHI) |