| | 2009 - Malcolm Jenkins - New Orleans Saints |
| | 2009 - Chris Wells - Arizona Cardinals |
| | 2008 - Vernon Gholston - New York Jets |
| | 2007 - Ted Ginn Jr. - Miami Dolphins |
| | 2007 - Anthony Gonzalez - Indianapolis Colts |
| | 2006 - A.J. Hawk - Green Bay Packers |
| | 2006 - Donte Whitner - Buffalo Bills |
| | 2006 - Bobby Carpenter - Dallas Cowboys |
| | 2006 - Santonio Holmes - Pittsburgh Steelers |
| | 2006 - Nick Mangold - New York Jets |
| | 2004 - Will Smith - New Orleans Saints |
| | 2004 - Chris Gamble - Carolina Panthers |
| | 2004 - Michael Jenkins - Atlanta Falcons |
| | 2001 - Nate Clements - Buffalo Bills |
| | 2001 - Ryan Pickett - St. Louis Rams |
| | 2000 - Ahmed Plummer - San Francisco 49ers |
| | 1999 - David Boston - Arizona Cardinals |
| | 1999 - Antoine Winfield - Buffalo Bills |
| | 1999 - Andy Katzenmoyer - New England Patriots |
| | 1997 - Orlando Pace - St. Louis Rams |
| | 1997 - Shawn Springs - Seattle Seahawks |
| | 1996 - Terry Glenn - New England Patriots |
| | 1996 - Rickey Dudley - Oakland Raiders |
| | 1996 - Eddie George - Houston Oilers |
| | 1995 - Joey Galloway - Seattle Seahawks |
| | 1995 - Korey Stringer - Minnesota Vikings |
| | 1995 - Craig Powell - Cleveland Browns |
| | 1994 - Dan Wilkinson - Cincinnati Bengals |
| | 1993 - Robert Smith - Minnesota Vikings |
| | 1992 - Alonzo Spellman - Chicago Bears |
| | 1991 - Vinnie Clark - Green Bay Packers |
| | 1988 - Eric Kumerow - Miami Dolphins |
| | 1986 - Keith Byars - Philadelphia Eagles |
| | 1985 - Jim Lachey - San Diego Chargers |
| | 1984 - William Roberts - New York Giants |
| | 1982 - Art Schlichter - Baltimore Colts |
| | 1979 - Tom Cousineau - Buffalo Bills |
| | 1978 - Chris Ward - New York Jets |
| | 1977 - Bob Brudzinski - Los Angeles Rams |
| | 1976 - Tim Fox - New England Patriots |
| | 1976 - Archie Griffin - Cincinnati Bengals |
| | 1975 - Kurt Schumacher - New Orleans Saints |
| | 1975 - Doug France - Los Angeles Rams |
| | 1975 - Neal Colzie - Oakland Raiders |
| | 1974 - John Hicks - New York Giants |
| | 1974 - Rick Middleton - New Orleans Saints |
| | 1974 - Randy Gradishar - Denver Broncos |
| | 1971 - John Brockington - Green Bay Packers |
| | 1971 - Jack Tatum - Oakland Raiders |
| | 1971 - Tim Anderson - San Francisco 49ers |
| | 1971 - Leo Hayden - Minnesota Vikings |
| | 1969 - Rufus Mayes - Chicago Bears |
| | 1969 - Dave Foley - New York Jets |
| | 1964 - Paul Warfield - Cleveland Browns |
| | 1963 - Bob Vogel - Baltimore Colts |
| | 1963 - Daryl Sanders - Detroit Lions |
| | 1962 - Bob Ferguson - Pittsburgh Steelers |
| | 1961 - Tom Matte - Baltimore Colts |
| | 1960 - Jim Houston - Cleveland Browns |
| | 1959 - Don Clark - Chicago Bears |
| | 1959 - Dan James - San Francisco 49ers |
| | 1957 - Jim Parker - Baltimore Colts |
| | 1956 - Howard (Hopalong) Cassady - Detroit Lions |
| | 1950 - Fred (Curly) Morrison - Chicago Bears |
| | 1941 - Don Scott - Chicago Bears |
| | 1938 - Jim McDonald - Philadelphia Eagles |