| | 1903 Pittsburgh Pirates, Boston Pilgrims |
| | 1904 n/a |
| | 1905 NY Giants, Phil A’s |
| | 1906 Chicago Cubs, Chicago White Sox |
| | 1907 Chicago Cubs, Detroit Tigers |
| | 1908 Chicago Cubs, Detroit Tigers |
| | 1909 Pittsburgh Pirates, Detroit Tigers |
| | 1910 Chicago Cubs, Phil A’s |
| | 1911 NY Giants, Phil A’s |
| | 1912 NY Giants, Boston Red Sox |
| | 1913 NY Giants, Phil A’s |
| | 1914 Boston Braves, Phil A’s |
| | 1915 Phil Phillies, Boston Red Sox |
| | 1916 Brooklyn Robins, Boston Red Sox |
| | 1917 NY Giants, ChicagoWhite Sox |
| | 1918 Chicago Cubs,Boston Red Sox |
| | 1919 Cin Reds, Chicago White Sox |
| | 1920 Brooklyn Robins, Cleveland Indians |
| | 1921 NY Giants, NY Yankees |
| | 1922 NY Giants, NY Yankees |
| | 1923 NY Giants, NY Yankees |
| | 1924 NY Giants, Washington Senators |
| | 1925 Pittsburgh Pirates, Washington Senators |
| | 1926 STL Cardinals, NY Yankees |
| | 1927 Pittsburgh Pirates, NY Yankees |
| | 1928 STL Cardinals, NY Yankees |
| | 1929 Chicago Cubs, Phil A’s |
| | 1930 STL Cardinals, Phil A’s |
| | 1931 STL Cardinals, Phil A’s |
| | 1932 Chicago Cubs, NY Yankees |
| | 1933 NY Giants, Washington Senators |
| | 1934 STL Cardinals, Detroit Tigers |
| | 1935 Chicago Cubs, Detroit Tigers |
| | 1936 NY Giants, NY Yankees |
| | 1937 NY Giants, NY Yankees |
| | 1938 Chicago Cubs, NY Yankees |
| | 1939 Cin Reds, NY Yankees |
| | 1940 Cin Reds, Detroit Tigers |
| | 1941 Brooklyn Dodgers, NY Yankees |
| | 1942 STL Cardinals, NY Yankees |
| | 1943 STL Cardinals, NY Yankees |
| | 1944 STL Cardinals, STL Browns |
| | 1945 Chicago Cubs, Detroit Tigers |
| | 1946 STL Cardinals, Boston Red Sox |
| | 1947 Brooklyn Dodgers, NY Yankees |
| | 1948 Boston Braves, Cleveland Indians |
| | 1949 Brooklyn Dodgers, NY Yankees |
| | 1950 Phil Phillies, NY Yankees |
| | 1951 NY Giants, NY Yankees |
| | 1952 Brooklyn Dodgers, NY Yankees |
| | 1953 Brooklyn Dodgers, NY Yankees |
| | 1954 NY Giants, Cleveland Indians |
| | 1955 Brooklyn Dodgers, NY Yankees |
| | 1956 Brooklyn Dodgers, NY Yankees |
| | 1957 Milwaukee Braves, NY Yankees |
| | 1958 Milwaukee Braves, NY Yankees |
| | 1959 LA Dodgers, Chicago White Sox |
| | 1960 Pittsburgh Pirates, NY Yankees |
| | 1961 Cin Reds, NY Yankees |
| | 1962 SF Giants, NY Yankees |
| | 1963 LA Dodgers, NY Yankees |
| | 1964 STL Cardinals, NY Yankees |
| | 1965 LA Dodgers, Minnesota Twins |
| | 1966 LA Dodgers, Baltimore Orioles |
| | 1967 STL Cardinals, Boston Red Sox |
| | 1968 STL Cardinals, Detroit Tigers |
| | 1969 NY Mets, Baltimore Orioles |
| | 1970 Cin Reds, Baltimore Orioles |
| | 1971 Pittsburgh Pirates, Baltimore Orioles |
| | 1972 Cin Reds, Oakland A’s |
| | 1973 NY Mets, Oakland A’s |
| | 1974 LA Dodgers, Oakland A’s |
| | 1975 Cin Reds, Boston Red Sox |
| | 1976 Cin Reds, NY Yankees |
| | 1977 LA Dodgers, NY Yankees |
| | 1978 LA Dodgers, NY Yankees |
| | 1979 Pittsburgh Pirates, Baltimore Orioles |
| | 1980 Phil Phillies, KC Royals |
| | 1981 LA Dodgers, NY Yankees |
| | 1982 STL Cardinals, Milwaukee Brewers |
| | 1983 Phil Phillies, Baltimore Orioles |
| | 1984 San Diego Padres, Detroit Tigers |
| | 1985 STL Cardinals, KC Royals |
| | 1986 NY Mets, Boston Red Sox |
| | 1987 STL Cardinals, Minnesota Twins |
| | 1988 LA Dodgers, Oakland A’s |
| | 1989 SF Giants, Oakland A’s |
| | 1990 Cin Reds, Oakland A’s |
| | 1991 Atl Braves, Minnesota Twins |
| | 1992 Atl Braves, Toronto Blue Jays |
| | 1993 Phil Phillies, Toronto Blue Jays |
| | 1994 n/a |
| | 1995 Atl Braves, Cleveland Indians |
| | 1996 Atl Braves, NY Yankees |
| | 1997 Florida Marlins, Cleveland Indians |
| | 1998 San Diego Padres, NY Yankees |
| | 1999 Atl Braves, NY Yankees |
| | 2000 NY Mets, NY Yankees |
| | 2001 Arizona Diamondbacks, NY Yankees |
| | 2002 SF Giants, Anaheim Angels |
| | 2003 Florida Marlins, NY Yankees |
| | 2004 STL Cardinals, Boston Red Sox |
| | 2005 Houston Astros, Chicago White Sox |