Print
This List
Email to
a Friend
Top Times Voters Got It Wrong on American Idol
WORSTS 
Tags: American Idol, contestants, voting, worst, America, wrong, Ruben, Daughtry, Doolittle
Over the past 6 seasons of American Idol, voters have gotten it right often (e.g. Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood). But all too often they have also gotten it wrong. Below are the top 10 biggest screw-ups voters made the past 6 seasons.
| 1. | Chris Daughtry finishing in 4th (Season 5) |
| 2. | Melinda Doolittle not making the finale (Season 6) |
| 3. | Mandisa finishing in 9th (Season 5) |
| 4. | Tamyra Gray finishing in 4th (Season 1) |
| 5. | Ruben Studdard beating Clay Aiken in the finale (Season 2) |
| 6. | Scott Savol making it to 5th place (Season 4) |
| 7. | Two of 'The Divas' (Jennifer Hudson and Latoya London) being voted off too early (Season 3) |
| 8. | Sanjaya Malakar Making the top 12 (Season 6) |
| 9. | Constantine Maroulis finishing in 6th (Season 4) |
| 10. | Mikalah Gordon being on the show, period (Season 4) |
Lister:
ListAfterList Wiki Contributors
Source:
Entertainment Wikia
Other lists of interest:
Current list rating:
5.00