| | 1955 - Johnny Podres, Brooklyn Dodgers, P |
| | 1956 - Don Larsen, New York Yankees, P |
| | 1957 - Lew Burdette, Milwaukee Braves, P |
| | 1958 - Bob Turley, New York Yankees, P |
| | 1959 - Larry Sherry Los Angeles Dodgers, P |
| | 1960 - Bobby Richardson, New York Yankees, 2B |
| | 1961 - Whitey Ford, New York Yankees, P |
| | 1962 - Ralph Terry, New York Yankees, P |
| | 1963 - Sandy Koufax, Los Angeles Dodgers, P |
| | 1964 - Bob Gibson, St. Louis Cardinals, P |
| | 1965 - Sandy Koufax, Los Angeles Dodgers, P |
| | 1966 - Frank Robinson, Baltimore Orioles, OF |
| | 1967 - Bob Gibson, St. Louis Cardinals, P |
| | 1968 - Mickey Lolich, Detroit Tigers, P |
| | 1969 - Donn Clendenon, New York Mets, 1B |
| | 1970 - Brooks Robinson, Baltimore Orioles, 3B |
| | 1971 - Roberto Clemente, Pittsburgh Pirates, OF |
| | 1972 - Gene Tenace, Oakland Athletics, C |
| | 1973 - Reggie Jackson, Oakland Athletics, OF |
| | 1974 - Rollie Fingers, Oakland Athletics, P |
| | 1975 - Pete Rose, Cincinnati Reds, 3B |
| | 1976 - Johnny Bench, Cincinnati Reds, C |
| | 1977 - Reggie Jackson, New York Yankees, OF |
| | 1978 - Bucky Dent, New York Yankees, SS |
| | 1979 - Willie Stargell, Pittsburgh Pirates, 1B |
| | 1980 - Mike Schmidt, Philadelphia Phillies, 3B |
| | 1981 - Pedro Guerrero, Los Angeles Dodgers, OF |
| | Tie - Ron Cey, Los Angeles Dodgers, 3B |
| | Tie - Steve Yeager, Los Angeles Dodgers, C |
| | 1982 - Darrell Porter, St. Louis Cardinals, C |
| | 1983 - Rick Dempsey, Baltimore Orioles, C |
| | 1984 - Alan Trammell, Detroit Tigers, SS |
| | 1985 - Bret Saberhagen, Kansas City Royals, P |
| | 1986 - Ray Knight, New York Mets, 3B |
| | 1987 - Frank Viola, Minnesota Twins, P |
| | 1988 - Orel Hershiser, Los Angeles Dodgers, P |
| | 1989 - Dave Stewart, Oakland Athletics, P |
| | 1990 - Jose Rijo, Cincinnati Reds, P |
| | 1991 - Jack Morris, Minnesota Twins, P |
| | 1992 - Pat Borders, Toronto Blue Jays, P |
| | 1993 - Paul Molitor, Toronto Blue Jays, DH/1B/3B |
| | 1994 - Not Played |
| | 1995 - Tom Glavine, Atlanta Braves, P |
| | 1996 - John Wetteland, New York Yankees, P |
| | 1997 - Livan Hernandez, Florida Marlins, P |
| | 1998 - Scott Brosius, New York Yankees, 3B |
| | 1999 - Mariano Rivera, New York Yankees, P |
| | 2000 - Derek Jeter, New York Yankees, SS |
| | 2001 - Randy Johnson, Arizona Diamondbacks, P |
| | 2001(Tie) - Curt Schilling, Arizona Diamondbacks, P |
| | 2002 - Troy Glaus, Anaheim Angels, 3B |
| | 2003 - Josh Beckett,Florida Marlins P |
| | 2004 - Manny Ramirez, Boston, OF |
| | 2005 - Jermaine Dye, Chicago, OF |
| | 2006 - David Eckstein, St Louis, SS |
| | 2007 - Mike Lowell, Boston Red Sox, 3B |